I hate my brother.
I don't use that word lightly...and yet, maybe I do, because I'm not one hundred percent sure what it means. I think the definition of hate is fluid, and perhaps different for different people. For me, I do believe I hate him.
Hate takes a lot of energy, consciously and not-so-consciously. One of the major symptoms of my depression is exhaustion; I don't have energy to spare. And it makes me even angrier that he takes so much of my energy away from me. That
I let him take that energy, because I don't know how to stop it. I would love to write him off completely, to cut him out of my life fully, but I've only been able to do so superficially. He lingers in the lining, sullen threads that refuse to be ripped away. I can keep him out of my line of sight. But I can't keep him out of my dreams, or my energy supply.
My parents always wanted a boy, so I guess it was inevitable that, while I asked for a sister, what they brought home would be...sub-par, to my five-year-old mind. He and I were complete opposites from the start. I'd been a quiet baby, a small baby. Underweight, solemn, but happy for attention. Foster parents and later my adoptive parents crowed that they could take me anywhere. I never cried or fussed. I sat in a stroller or someone's arms, big eyes watching everything. Eventually I fell asleep.
From the minute he came home, Nathan was different. He was loud, and fat - not just double chins, but three or four, depending on his position. He was always hot, so the huge mat of black hair on top of his head constantly dripped. He screamed. He wiggled. His birth mother was a drug addict, his birth father a Mexican national. My parents adored him from the start.
As he grew, I like to think there were warning signs, but this was the late 80's and early 90's. I have no idea whether there were psychiatrists, psychologists, or other professionals considering that toddler misbehavior was anything but that: a normal phase for toddlers to go through.
When he was two, Nathan had a bad anaphylactic reaction to peanut butter, and was rushed to the hospital. Peanuts, peanut butter, and even the special peanut butter cookies I made with my grandma, were outlawed from the house. I complained bitterly, especially about the cookies. That was something special I did with my grandma, from a recipe handed down through the family. My brother was now encroaching not only on my house, my parents, and my life there, but also my special time with my grandmother, who I adored.
I distinctly remember one incident, where I was frustrated by something he'd done. He was still in a crib. I took all of the stuffed animals in the house - mine, his, my mother's, and the ones from the daycare she ran out of the garage - and piled them over him in his crib. My parents snapped photos; they thought it was cute that I was "sharing." In reality, I was trying to bury him. To keep him contained, from infiltrating more and more into my world, pushing me out. I had the normal jealousy of a kid who suddenly has a younger sibling, but things didn't settle down. The older he got, the worse it became. And I wasn't a stupid kid. I knew my parents wanted a boy; that I was a foster kid they'd chosen to keep, whereas
he'd been searched for, sought after, yearned for. The fishing, hiking, and camping trips with my dad ended, very abruptly. He didn't need to pretend with me anymore. He had a
real son now.
Except, there was something wrong with Nathan, something neither of my parents wanted to either see or admit. His Terrible Twos stretched into Terrible Threes, then Fours, Fives, Sixes.
Like any home with small children, the refrigerator in our house was decorated with my artwork. He would rip it to pieces. Not just as a baby who you'd expect not to know better, but all throughout his childhood. "You can't get mad at him," my mother would tell me, while she held him and stroked his hair. "He's impulsive. He can't help himself."
But it wasn't just artwork - nothing in the house was safe from him. I was forced, extremely unwillingly, to share my toys, most of which he then broke. My mother scolded me, and said I was a selfish, mean girl, and needed to share. I shared great at school (and latchkey programs, after we moved and my mother no longer had her own daycare). With other children, she scolded that I was too trusting, that I shouldn't share so much. Other children were mean and greedy; they'd take my things and wouldn't give them back. Nathan, though? Nathan was a saint. He never did anything wrong in her eyes and if he did, "You can't get mad at him for it."
I thought we were pretty poor growing up, especially after we moved away from San Diego and my beloved grandma. I didn't get much in the way of new toys or clothes, and what clothes I did get often came from thrift stores or hand-me-downs from older cousins. Turns out, we weren't nearly as bad off as I'd assumed. My parents were just terrified of debt, to the point where every cent they made went, not to toys or vacations or good food, but to paying off their mortgage. I don't blame them for the choice they made - it was their money. But, growing up, I sincerely believed we were one breath away from a homeless shelter, which was far from reality. I can remember being so sick of rice, and begging for potatoes instead, and my mother saying no, that rice was cheaper than potatoes. She was probably right...by a few cents.
One Christmas, though, I got a model horse. He was just an off-brand thing, about the size of the branded Barbie horses that were all the rage. But I loved him. He was jointed, so you could pretend to walk him around and pose him. I loved that horse from the minute I saw him. He was the only toy I got that Christmas - I got some clothes, too, I think, and we all had stockings with an orange, an apple, and maybe some candy. But for me, that horse was my whole Christmas and I
loved him.
That afternoon, Christmas afternoon, my mother told me to share my new horse with my brother. I refused. I
knew he'd break it. I got called cruel, and heartless, and told that
this was Christmas, and eventually she took the toy from me and gave it to him.
He snapped one of the legs off within ten seconds, just like I knew he would.
My dad glued the leg back together, but it wouldn't move anymore. My jointed horse was permanently crippled the day I got it, because my mother made me "share" it when I
knew it would only get broken if I did.
This wasn't a singular episode; it happened over and over in the house. I had a beautiful shimmering kite of translucent plastic with a unicorn on it - a prized possession. Going to the park and flying my kite while my parents tried to relax and chased after Nathan was one of my favorite things. My mother made me "let Nathan have a turn." He threw the string in the air and laughed. No more kite.
And the thing was, every single time, I
knew what was going to happen. I knew he was going to break or lose my things, and I didn't have a lot to begin with. When I tried to protest, I got called mean, cruel, selfish, heartless, a witch...the names went on and on. And when the inevitable happened, they didn't see the pattern I saw. They said I wasn't allowed to be angry, or blame him. They never offered to replace anything.
The last thing he ruined was the pet dog.
Mozart was a purebred German Shepherd, given to us because he had a limp as a puppy. The breeders, friends of my fathers, bred and trained dogs for the local police department. We were living in Salem, Oregon by this point, after many, many moves. He was a gangly black and tan thing, small and staggering, with huge bat ears and an almost bald belly. I'm a cat person, but I don't mind dogs. I was thirteen or fourteen by this time. I slept in the garage with the puppy when he whined, because he wasn't used to being alone and my parents didn't want him sleeping in the house until he was housebroken.
I named him Mozart, in the hope that it would give the awkward little bat-puppy some elegance to grow into. The family almost immediately shortened it to Moe - as in, one of the Three Stooges. My parents soon found out that a dog bred for police work doesn't necessarily make a good family pet. He failed puppy kindergarten. Eventually they took him to a trainer who specialized in German Shepherds, and that seemed to help, but Moe needed a job to do. He was too smart and too energetic to just sit at home. I did my best - I would run with him in the evenings, around and around the neighborhood. He loved it. But he was still a Shepherd bred for work, work that as a pet he just wasn't getting. He bit me once - I still have a scar on my palm. He bit my mother. Oddly enough, he was terrified of the two cats in the house, and would whine and turn tail when they hissed at him.
My mom suffers from undiagnosed chronic pain, and taking such a big, energetic dog out became too much for her. My brother was forbidden to take him out alone - at least my parents got one thing right. My dad started to work more and more, and was never home. My mother poured her love into that dog; Moe was her baby just as much as Nathan was. But as Moe became less and less socialized, he became more and more protective and territorial. We so rarely had anyone in the house that he didn't react well around strangers. The rule was made that Moe should be locked up in the laundry room if anyone came to the house.
Time passed; we moved again. This last move was beyond the last straw for me; I was done. I wanted nothing more from these people, because they didn't seem to care what I thought and felt. I was tired of the name-calling, the blame, the isolation. I moved to Virginia for college, and was glad to go. Later I heard through my grandmother - my mother, for whatever reason, wouldn't tell me herself - that the dog had to be put down. Nathan had had a friend or two over - something I was never allowed to do when I lived there - and he had, against all rules and common sense, let the dog out. Moe bit one of the boys, and that was the end of it. My mother loved that dog like a child, but it didn't matter. There were never any consequences, any punishment, any recrimination, for Nathan. Only for the dog, who didn't know any better.
I'm frustrated with my parents for the way our family functioned, yes, but I don't hate them. I do hate my brother. If he'd never been part of my life, things wouldn't have been perfect, but they'd have been better. I truly believe that. Maybe my parents would have noticed me. Maybe when they saw me struggling, hurting, they would have had the time and energy to care. Maybe I would have been allowed to have friends over. Maybe I would have been allowed to have friends, period. Maybe I'd have a sense of home - what home is, and what it's supposed to be.
I haven't been in the same room with my brother in at least three years, maybe longer. I have a deep sense of relief, but also of waiting for the other shoe to drop. He's not dead. I can't escape him forever. What do I do regarding family get-togethers, weddings, etc? Saying, "I'll come if Nathan isn't going to be there," is still letting him run my life, like he did all through my childhood.
In my perfect world, he'd be committed, locked in a facility somewhere, where he can't hurt anybody. My parents won't admit the physical violence that was pervasive in our house, growing up. But it was there, and it all came from him. He hurt my mom all the time. He hurt the animals in the household. He hurt me until I got big enough to scare him, when I was twelve or so. Even then, there was "physical violence" toward me, in that he had no respect for my boundaries. He knew I didn't like to be touched, particularly by him, so he would lick me, or poke me, or rub up against me. If I pushed him away with a hand or a foot, I got in trouble. He thought it was hilarious, while I felt sickened and like I wanted to take a hot shower and scrub it all away, every single time. I got so mad and frustrated, I would crawl into my closet and cry, because there was nothing I could do. I was powerless.
His violence was strange to me. It didn't stem from anger, necessarily. It just...was. And it wasn't just childish accident. I was visiting my parents for a brief time while my brother was in college, still living at home (an option never offered to me). My mother had an old, retired greyhound she had adopted, a quiet female unsteady on her feet and slowly dying of cancer. My brother was in the kitchen, and he saw the dog coming into the room. He grabbed the refrigerator door and slammed it open in her face, causing her to fall down. As she struggled to right herself in the narrow space, he howled with laughter. Just one of many incidents. He always hated the fruit we got in our stockings at Christmas, so he would throw his apple and orange at one or another of us as he pulled it from the stocking. Now that he's older, he's obsessed with weapons. Not guns as far as I know, but knives, swords, bows and arrows. He's not a hunter, but he carries a ridiculously oversized hunting knife around with him like normal people might carry a little pocket knife.
He worked at the YMCA for a short time in high school, monitoring the game room. An infraction including inappropriate contact with an underage girl made the Y offer him a choice: quit or be fired. He chose to quit, and so there's nothing on his record.
And now he's married. My mother always said she wanted him to go straight from her care to the care of a good wife, and it seems she got her wish. I pity the girl, but it was her choice. The ones who don't have a choice, however, are the kids they claim to want. His wife had a miscarriage a year or so ago, and I've studiously been ignoring any hints of information about this plan. He's unemployed, and has been for quite some time. And I'm so afraid for any kid that might come into that home. But what can I do? I don't think I can do anything except separate myself from the situation, and I don't think I'm doing even that particularly well.
So why do I say I hate him? To me, it's this: I don't want him to have a happy life. Childish as it sounds, he fucked up my childhood, and it's not fair. I want bad stuff to happen to him. I want him to suffer. If he needed an organ transplant to live, I wouldn't get tested to see if I was a match. I wouldn't give it to him. I hope his wife, who seems to be a genuinely gentle, caring girl, divorces him before anything too awful happens to her.
Mostly, I want my parents to acknowledge that all of this happened, and that it hurt me. I want them to own up to everything. I want an apology. And I know I'll never get one. So what happens now? What can I do to heal, knowing I'll never get what I want from them?